May 18, 2012

Arizona Medical Marijuana Ruling Highlights Risks When Cannabis Investments, Partnerships Sour

News about medical marijuana laws, pot legislation and cannabis regulations

What legal recourse do lenders have if a medical marijuana business defaults on its loan? None, apparently.

At least that’s the case for two individuals in Arizona who provided $500,000 in loans to Today’s Health Care II, a dispensary located in Colorado Springs, Colorado. The lenders filed a lawsuit in Arizona, claiming that the medical marijuana center failed to repay the loan on time and did not cover interest and other fees as stipulated in a written agreement between the two sides.

But the judge dismissed the lawsuit, saying he could not enforce a loan contract tied to medical marijuana because the drug is still illegal federally.

“The explicitly stated purpose of these loan agreements was to finance the sale and distribution of marijuana,” the judge wrote in the ruling. “This was in clear violation of the laws of the United States. As such, this contract is void and unenforceable.”

It’s an extremely negative development for medical marijuana professionals, as it has the potential to destroy a fundamental pillar of business for the MMJ industry: the option to take legal action if another party violates an agreement.

The implications could be significant.

If other judges follow the same reasoning, companies involved in the medical marijuana space could find themselves without legal protection on any matter involving a contract or agreement. That would deter everyone from lawyers and landlords to bankers and insurance companies from doing business with the MMJ industry, and it would present another huge challenge for cannabis businesses that are looking for financing.

Khurshid Khoja, principal of Greenbridge Corporate Counsel in San Francisco, told MMJ Business Daily that the ruling “is indeed problematic.”

But he said medical marijuana companies have another way to resolve contract disputes: arbitration. If the parties agree ahead of time – and in writing – to work out differences via this process rather than litigation, they can sidestep the courts and therefore avoid the issue involved in the Arizona case.

“These arbitration provisions are enforceable even in contracts that courts might deem unlawful given the current conflict between state and federal laws on cannabis, Khoja said. “This means that the courts are barred from intervening in a contractual dispute between parties to an arbitration agreement except in instances where consent to the arbitration agreement itself was fraudulently obtained. I think we’ll see the widespread use of broad arbitration provisions to mitigate the damage” of the Arizona ruling.


One Comment:

  1. I am the Arizona lawyer who broke the story of this case on May 7, 2012, when I published a story called “Maricopa County Superior Court Ruling May be Last Nail in the Coffin of the Unborn Arizona Medical Marijuana Dispensary Industry.” Read more about this case on my Arizona Medical Marijuana Law website here:

    http://www.keytlaw.com/arizonamedicalmarijuanalaw/

    My website has the latest news about Arizona medical marijuana law.

Post Your Comment:


Please note:
Comments are moderated by our editors who do their best to approve comments ASAP. As Marijuana Business Daily is focused on business, we approve comments that are specifically relevant to industry professionals. General opinions and questions about cannabis may not be posted.

Arizona Businesses, Advocates Unite Behind Single MJ Measure

The formerly fractured Arizona marijuana community emerged as a united front on Friday, with representatives [click to continue...]

Heads of Illinois, New Jersey Medical Cannabis Programs Step Down

resignation letter

Medical marijuana programs in two states are looking for new leaders. Bob Morgan, the coordinator [click to continue...]

2 Marijuana Measures Filed for 2016 Ballot in California

A pair of proposed 2016 ballot measures tied to cannabis have been filed with the [click to continue...]

Gupta: U.S. Needs Medical Marijuana ‘Revolution’

CNN’s chief medical correspondent Sanjay Gupta gave the medical marijuana industry another shot in the [click to continue...]

National Association for Cannabis Lawyers to Launch

marijuana lawsuit

Two California lawyers have teamed up to start the National Cannabis Bar Association, with the [click to continue...]

Union Nixes Attempt to Organize Workers at NJ Dispensary

Marijuana businesses hoping for some potential legal guidance on unionization from a case in New [click to continue...]

CA Judge Won’t Reschedule Marijuana

A federal judge in California on Wednesday declined to overturn marijuana’s place on the Drug [click to continue...]

Bill Rolling Washington MMJ Into Recreational Program Advances

WashingtonCannabis

Washington State Gov. Jay Inslee will likely sign a bill passed by the Legislature that [click to continue...]

New Jersey Dispensary in Labor Dispute Turned Away By Law Firm

Some attorneys still won’t touch the cannabis industry, it seems. David Knowlton, co-founder of the [click to continue...]

Delaware’s 1st Dispensary Delayed Again, Set For June Opening

The opening of Delaware’s first and only MMJ dispensary has been delayed again, but this [click to continue...]

Millions More Devoted to New York MMJ Industry

NewYorkMedicalMarijuana

Even though New York hasn’t even begun issuing business licenses yet for medical marijuana companies, [click to continue...]

Illinois Gov Won’t Extend MMJ Pilot Program Yet

In response to attempts by lawmakers to extend the timeline for the state’s medical cannabis [click to continue...]

Filings Show Many Banks Working With Cannabis Businesses

Banks have filed more than 1,700 so-called “marijuana limited” suspicious activity reports since the federal [click to continue...]

New Doctor Requirement Could Dampen Arizona’s MMJ Market

arizona medical cannabis

Arizona dispensaries could see fewer new patients after the state’s governor signed a bill forcing [click to continue...]