Cannabis Industry Awaits Ruling in Long-Running Lawsuit Over Federal Pre-emption

, Cannabis Industry Awaits Ruling in Long-Running Lawsuit Over Federal Pre-emption

By Omar Sacirbey

Arizona attorney Steven White is leaving the legal profession to concentrate on his marijuana business, but he’s fighting perhaps the biggest battle of his career before moving on.

White argued his last case on March 3 in a lawsuit pitting his client – plaintiff White Mountain Health Center of Sun City, Arizona – against Maricopa County, which is trying to prevent the dispensary from opening.

The outcome of the case has national implications that could reverberate across not only Arizona, but also every state with legalized medical or recreational marijuana.

If White Mountain loses, the ruling could set a legal precedent for marijuana foes to wreak havoc on the cannabis industry, threatening dispensaries, cultivation sites and other businesses.

The case goes all the way back to 2012 and is now being heard in the Arizona Appellate Court.

Lawyers for Maricopa County, including noted prohibitionist Bill Montgomery, argue that the municipality is entitled to deny the dispensary a permit to open because the business violates the federal Controlled Substances Act given that it sells marijuana. They also argue that federal law pre-empts Arizona’s MMJ program.

A ruling is expected in two or three months, said White, who believes the panel of judges will rule against federal “pre-emption.”

Nonetheless, he said, industry supporters need to be wary of the threat.

“The issue that is most important for the industry at large is the pre-emption issue,” said White, CEO of Harvest of Tempe, a cultivation, processing and dispensary business that now has operations in its home state plus Nevada and Illinois. “Not everybody knows that this case is still going on. People presume that when this case was won at the trial court level, that was going to be the end.”

He added that many people don’t realize that the case is still alive and “is subject to being overturned.”

“We as an industry have to be pretty vigilante to ensure that that doesn’t happen,” White said.

Indeed, given the rapid pace of legalization over the last few years and the potential that several more states could allow recreational or medical marijuana this year, it’s easy to take legalization for granted.

But the pre-emption threat is not to be taken lightly.

One of the Arizona Appellate Court judges, Donn Kessler, told White Mountain’s lawyers, “Whatever you’re doing, you can’t violate federal law,” according to

Similar arguments are being made elsewhere.

Last March, Nebraska and Kansas sued Colorado over its recreational marijuana program, asserting that federal law has supremacy over state law.

Federal pre-emption is an argument used often by local municipalities or private individuals who want to prevent marijuana businesses from opening within their borders, although so far it hasn’t been successful, attorneys said.

“The federal government can regulate marijuana and does, but states don’t have to enforce federal law,” said Ilya Shapiro, an attorney and states’ rights expert at the Cato Institute in Washington DC. “If the state wants to enforce federal law, it can do that, but if it doesn’t want to, then a private party can’t force it to.”

Professor Robert Mikos of Vanderbilt University Law School, who studies the issue, agreed.

He wrote an amicus brief in a 2013 Michigan case where John Ter Beek, a medical marijuana cardholder who grew his own medicine, sued the town in Wyoming where he lived for imposing an ordinance against cannabis cultivation.

Ter Beek lost at the district court level but appealed and won, including at the Michigan Supreme Court, where justices ruled that the federal Controlled Substances Act did not pre-empt Michigan’s medical marijuana law.

One of the attorneys who argued that case was Emma Anderson of the American Civil Liberties Union, who also argued the White Mountain case with attorney Steven White.

Mikos believes the Arizona case will play out like the Ter Beek case.

“If all Arizona is saying is ‘we are not going to punish people who buy and sell marijuana for medical or other purposes,’ they’re constitutionally entitled to do that,” Mikos said. “The key point is that state law is not pre-empted to the extent that it merely allows people to do something that’s forbidden under federal law.”

However, while states don’t have to enforce federal law, they can’t stop federal law enforcement officials from enforcing federal laws, which is why marijuana businesses in California and other states were defenseless against federal raids in years past.

“They can’t stop the federal government from coming in cracking down on these people,” Mikos said.

Those raids have subsided since the 2013 Department of Justice Cole Memo, which essentially said the federal government will not make enforcing federal marijuana laws a priority in states with legalized marijuana.

While the Cole Memo has taken some of the federal heat off state-licensed marijuana businesses, it still can’t stop a party from launching a federal pre-emption claim against a state, even though it might fail like past pre-emption cases.

“If you’ve got a governor or some other senior state official who says ‘I can’t implement this medical marijuana licensing regime because it’s pre-empted by federal law, maybe that official is wrong but at least for the time being, those businesses that wanted to take advantage of these laws are going to be out of luck, they’re going to have to file their own legal challenges,” Mikos said.

The best defense against pre-emption, attorneys said, is the 10th Amendment of the Constitution, which says that powers not given to the federal government by the Constitution, and not prohibited by it to the states, will belong to the states.

‘The federal government can’t force the states to criminalize private behavior. They can’t force a state like Arizona or Michigan to ban the possession or distribution of marijuana,” Mikos said.

Omar Sacirbey can be reached at [email protected]

6 comments on “Cannabis Industry Awaits Ruling in Long-Running Lawsuit Over Federal Pre-emption
  1. Desert Woman on

    change needs to come at the federal level. how much longer can pretend that cannabis is harmful? they need to accept research and science and stop touting nonsense

    • Robert Hempaz, PhD Trichometry on

      Hillary wants to drop Cannabis and Hemp from Schedule I to Schedule II … to allow deeper investigation medically into the DNA structure of the plant by research type Universities. Trump is wishy-washy on the issue, as he is wishy-washy on just about every issue! However, Wishy-washy rules this election! At least until the General Election in November ’16. Expect #RecMj to become legal in the State of Arizona via another slim, yet successful #MPP petition final vote count (including absentee and early votes).

  2. Ronald Coquis on

    Dear Sirs, I introduce myself, my name is Ronald Coquis, I Counsel and international broker of industrial hemp, I’ve been growing and transforming this plant about 7 years in the Czech Republic, Austria and Romania, and about 4 years in Spain researching and planting different varieties seed in different climates and altitudes, as well as collaborating with different technological institutes and European and American companies working with this wonderful plant more than 300 years ago.

    In the past 4 years there have been an infinite number of studies of cannabinoids, especially the CBD and THC in different private laboratories, technical institutes, universities, hospitals and Sick in General, in the fight against cancer and many other diseases that has been proven effective against physical damage caused and particularly alleviate pain, providing a better quality of life.

    We follow methods of special and expensive cultivation for better derivative of cannabinoids when our goal is medicinal, so we have sown in Huelva, Cordoba, Seville, Galicia, Czech Republic, Austria and soon in Uruguay and Central America in El Salvador where a large processing industry develops MANUAL.

    We have a R & D department that works directly with universities, technology institutes and European and American laboratories as in the case of El Salvador and the University of El Salvador School of Chemistry and Pharmacy and the Laboratory of Natural Products Research, FqF-UES with whom we develop studies of the derivative or drug withdrawals we get industrial hemp as the CBD, CBDA, THCV, CBDV, THCA, CBG and CBC, 100% Bio Organic.

    A few years I’ve been helping many farmers to plant, tend, harvest and transform this plant in Spain and America, with little success at first, since little information and experience about this crop and the lack of knowledge of laws let you plant these seeds without problems, let a lot of mistrust among farmers for its resemblance to marijuana, in addition to the question of who will guarantee the purchase of production.

    When we started we experienced 5 hectares in different climates and altitudes, this year 2015 we have planted 180 hectares in Spain, 277 from the Czech Republic and Austria, and soon 300 in Uruguay for Biodiesel and 400 in El Salvador for fibers, oils and teas for USA and we continue to grow and help more families and entrepreneurs to meet this alternative agricultural future.

    Since 2010 my client base in Europe and America has grown each year marketing guaranteeing me all production including that of my collaborators or partners and I mean; My current demand exceeds 1500 hectares and only 47% weeknight. We have a profitable agricultural alternative !!!

    Each farmer works different formats of raw materials such as cellulose fibers for Trash, isolation techniques, textiles, construction cañamiza for Bio, seeds oils, proteins, etc. and Flores and Medicinal Teas, allowing to grow slowly in order to get to industrialize this plant in Spain.

    The peculiarity of the climate of Spain, allow me to have two crops in the south compared to Eastern Europe that has only one crop a year, hence the demand in these countries is greater than their annual harvest, which is why part of my production is destined to different parts of the world, but 60% go to the Netherlands, with great surprise that we discovered that 37% of our raw material returns to Spain, in different presentation formats with Brand and Sanitary Registration .

    70% of our production is ecological BIO (image attached document) and our experience allows us to develop a successful agriculture and transform different raw materials in Spain and other transformations in the Czech Republic and Austria where there are machines and / or industrialization, for now we do not.

    1. COGOLLOS with seeds and branches (TEAS AND EXTRACTS)
    2. leaves with seeds WITHOUT RAMA (100% OF DEMAND)
    4. SEEDS FOR POWER TO 7% OF MOISTURE (oils, proteins, etc.)
    7. peeled fibers (TECHNICAL INSULATION, rope, textiles, etc.)

    1. PELADAS SEEDS (omega 3, 6 and 9)
    2. PROTEIN
    3. MEALS
    4. OIL


    Today, September 2015, a group of professionals have gathered in Madrid to develop a clinical trial of our products in which 20 patients by choice and with different diseases were part of this project.

    It is within a protected area and prepared for the patient and the doctors who were in charge of monitoring and evaluation of the results are within a comfortable and safe for both environment and also our intention is that these tests are FREE and the most important They can repeat these tests every year.

    We have three delivery formats abroad:

    1. RESEARCH: these products are only in a closed circuit patients and physicians, and where under consent of the patient experience, new palliative their body aches or pains alternatives. These products are free to patients who belong to associations that collaborate with us.

    2. WHOLESALE: as farmers and processors produce different end products.

    3. unbranded products (Product White): manufacture of end products brand, and packaged or labeled by us in the printing of the Czech Republic, the customer has trademark, veterinary, etc.

    4. PRODUCTS WITH OUR BRAND; Packaged and marketed by our company, Hemp Solution, sro under strict quality controls, and directly from our headquarters in the Czech Republic or Spain.


    At the moment we are able to create these products legally in the Czech Republic and Austria, which will be made available to patients in this project, and are as follows:

    1. CBD GLASS TO 98% purity
    to. CBD Hemp Oil 20mg capsules
    b. CBD Hemp Oil 30mg capsules
    c. CBD Hemp Oil 60mg capsules
    d. Hemp Oil 30mg capsules CBG
    e. Hemp Oil 60mg capsules CBG
    3. Format CBD CREAM
    4. Format CBD OINTMENTS

    Finally tell you that from the Czech Republic, we have the possibility to get them INDUSTRIAL HEMP SEEDS CERTIFIED BY THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITY for Food and medicinal use, we work with varieties of Eastern Europe, as we consider the best for our purposes .

    Of all ways dear friends know you have many questions, they know that I can find in my SKYPE; lacasadenoah, my emails are [email protected] or [email protected] my cell; 655611228 or 692686242, 958977022, Let me an email and I sent a file with pictures of our work.

    Ronald Coquis

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *