Battling insurers in the aftermath of lootings: Q&A with California cannabis executive Keith Stephenson

Did you miss the webinar “Women Leaders in Cannabis: Shattering the Grass Ceiling?” Head to MJBiz YouTube to watch it now!

Keith Stevenson; Purple Heart cannabis, Battling insurers in the aftermath of lootings: Q&A with California cannabis executive Keith Stephenson

Keith Stephenson’s 14-year-old Oakland cannabis shop, Purple Heart Patient Center, was one of scores that were ransacked the weekend of May 29 during widespread Black Lives Matter protests in California and across the nation.

Having shuttered in March as a precaution during the initial coronavirus outbreak, Purple Heart has been closed for roughly five months, racking up immense sales losses.

For the past two months, Stephenson, Purple Heart’s founder and CEO, has been battling with his insurance carrier so he can repair and reopen his battered store.

It’s an ordeal that other cannabis business owners will want to follow to understand what to expect in such situations.

Marijuana Business Daily spoke with Stephenson about how he’s been handling the situation.

Have you reopened yet?

Not yet. I’ve been closed since March 20 for COVID, and we were just about to open when we sustained this burglary. So I’ve been closed for five months.

I’ve had three adjusters in a matter of three months. There was a feeling like the onus or the burden was placed on me. It was kind of like, “Did we have something to do with this?”

I told the adjuster, “You could either file this claim, or you can file a police report for me filing a false police report. Something’s got to give, because you can tell this is forced entry. Do you think we had anything to do with it?”

I feel like they don’t want to pay – not my claim, but the industry’s claims. It’s quite worrisome.

I would say the adjuster hasn’t been honest in some ways. I just started cc’ing my attorney on all correspondence, and that has changed the momentum of how they’re dealing with this.

It sounds like the insurance company’s been stalling to get out of paying your claim.

We’re not reopened. They say, “Call a contractor and get an estimate.”

They don’t directly say that it’s overpriced, but they say, “Now we want to bring our contractor out.”

So they do that, and their contractor completely lowballs it, and it’s not even apples to apples.

Now you have two bids, and they say, “We need you to get a third bid.”

So you get a third bid, and that takes time. It’s an extremely cumbersome process.

What they’re asking for is not normal, and I think everyone in the industry needs to be prepared to have a team that can assemble these financial records pretty promptly.

What’s your advice to others in the same situation?

You have the insurer trying to find a way to deny as many claims as they can.

And I’d say the most important thing is to cc your attorney on every correspondence.

The adjuster removes our corporate counsel off the correspondence, and I politely ask them, “Please don’t do that.”

Once they understood that I have counsel, then it started going differently.

These are just growing pains our industry has to deal with.

Give them everything they ask for, even if you don’t necessarily agree, because the goal is for them to pay on the claim.

Everyone should be extremely honest. These adjusters have seen everything under the sun, so don’t try to add anything to it. But also, don’t remove anything that needs to be part of the claim.

Is this the first time you’ve had to go through a process like this? 

Yes (it’s the first), but I wouldn’t say it’s been a nightmare. It’s been less than comfortable.

A nightmare would have been if we hadn’t had insurance. Having said that, you really have to hold their feet to the fire and give them what they want, but not toe the line, because everyone who works for them works on behalf of the insurance company.

They’re working to pay the least amount possible to settle the claim.

I have an $850 deadbolt. He wrote up an $85 lock. There were things that were damaged that they didn’t even mention in (the insurance contractor’s) bid.

Don’t expect the insurance company to work for you.

Do you have any idea when Purple Heart might be able to reopen? Could it be a few more months?

I should hope not, but you have so many moving parts.

You have an adjuster who has several other cannabis claims.

And if they’re just looking for a needle in a haystack for each claim, how productive can they be?

Communication hasn’t always been responsive. I’m saying, “I need to pay the rent.”

But they don’t want to take care of anything until they figure out how much they need to pay out and when the forensic accountant gets back to them.

And if you do choose to pay for (repairs) out of pocket, they’re surely going to contest it and say you overpaid for something. You just have to be patient and sit back and let them get through it.

How much is your claim going to be worth once it’s processed?

I have no idea. But I know (one company), their claim is like $2 million. And some of the other (marijuana stores) in Oakland, their claims are teetering on $1 million.

Are you worried at all about the future of Purple Heart?

I’m absolutely confident we’ll be back open for business. It’s just a question of when.

Having been closed since March, any idea how much you’ve lost in sales?

It could easily be $4.5 million.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

John Schroyer can be reached at